StarCraft 2 Melee Map Contest
submit to reddit


Review this Entry

You must log in to review contest entries.

User Reviews

  • Danzell rated this entry 3 out of 5

    it definetly needs more expansion as dimfish said
    it`s a detailed map that needs small improvements to balance the sides a bit.

    Captain
    avatar
  • dimfish rated this entry 2 out of 5

    This map obviously has some love and effort put into it, although I think it needs some major changes to become a solid map.

    First, the bases look more like Warcraft 3 bases than starcraft bases. Specifically, the resources should be placed away from the very edge of the base so that units and buildings can be placed behind them--battles around a mineral line are an important part of starcraft! Also, the main ramp/choke is very important, if it is too big then rushing strategies are very likely to win. It's up the map maker to balance this issue out, and I think these ramps are too large, and even the SW base has a larger ramp than the other bases.

    Second, starcraft maps simply need more expansions. The reason is that starcraft asks the player to decide between investing in more economy (bases and workers), army units, or technology. If there are little or no possible expansions then a major factor of the game is missing.

    Visually this map shows skill, but for your next one I think it should be more Starcrafty!

    Private
    avatar
    Battle.net
    Name:
    dimfish#490
    Realm:
    US Beta

Support Nibbits by linking to us: